In search of Darkish Matter, They Detected One other Thriller


It may very well be a key to the key of the universe. Or simply annoying background noise, one other merchandise to be calibrated in future experiments.

A crew of scientists looking darkish matter has recorded suspicious pings coming from a vat of liquid xenon beneath a mountain in Italy. They don’t seem to be claiming to have found darkish matter — or something, for that matter — but. However these pings, they are saying, may very well be tapping out a brand new view of the universe.

If the sign is actual and persists, the scientists say, it might be proof of a species of subatomic particles referred to as axions — lengthy theorized to play an important function in conserving nature symmetrical however by no means seen — streaming from the solar.

“It’s not darkish matter however discovering a brand new particle could be phenomenal,” stated Elena Aprile of Columbia College, who leads the Xenon Collaboration, the challenge that made the detection.

In an announcement, the collaboration stated that detecting the axions would have “a big influence on our understanding of elementary physics, but additionally on astrophysical phenomena.”

However there are different explanations for the discovering. As an alternative of axions, the scientists might have detected a brand new, surprising property of the slippery ghostly particles referred to as neutrinos. One more equally probably clarification is that their detector has been contaminated by vanishingly tiny quantities of tritium, a uncommon radioactive type of hydrogen.

The collaboration posted a paper describing the results to its website on Wednesday.

Or it might all simply be a statistical fluctuation that may go away with extra information. Members of Dr. Aprile’s crew conceded that the very best clarification that they had proper now — that axions have been responsible — has two possibilities in 10,000 of being a fluke, a far cry from the “5-sigma” criterion of lower than one probability in one million wanted in particle physics to certify a “discovery.”

“We wish to be very clear that each one we’re reporting is remark of an extra (a reasonably vital one) and never a discovery of any variety,” stated Evan Shockley of the College of Chicago in an e mail.

Frank Wilczek, a Nobel laureate on the Massachusetts Institute of Know-how who was one of many first physicists to suggest the axion, famous the collaboration’s personal caveats within the paper. However he stated it was “actually intriguing, and the physics group will probably be eagerly awaiting additional developments.”

Different scientists responded with cautious pleasure, or excited warning.

“I’m making an attempt to be calm right here, but it surely’s laborious to not be hyperbolic,” stated Neal Weiner, a particle theorist at New York College. “If that is actual, calling it a sport changer could be an understatement.”

Michael Turner, a cosmologist with the Kavli Basis in Los Angeles, referred to as the Xenon collaboration “a good looking experiment.”

“I actually wish to imagine it, however I believe it’ll most likely break my coronary heart,” he stated. “However for now, I’m excited that it may very well be one thing new and essential that cheers us all up.”

Dr. Aprile’s Xenon experiment is at present the biggest and most delicate in an alphabet soup of efforts aimed toward detecting and figuring out darkish matter, the mysterious substance that astronomers have concluded swamps the universe, outweighing unusual atomic matter by an element of 5 to 1.

In fashionable cosmology, darkish matter is the key sauce of the universe. It collects in invisible clouds, attracting unusual atomic matter into lumps that finally mild up as stars and galaxies.

The perfect guess is that this darkish matter consists of clouds of unique subatomic particles left over from the Massive Bang and identified generically as WIMPs, for weakly interacting large particles, a whole lot or hundreds of instances extra large than a hydrogen atom.

The Xenon Collaboration is a multinational crew of 163 scientists from 28 establishments and 11 nations. In a tunnel a mile underneath the rock on the Gran Sasso Nationwide Laboratory in Italy, Dr. Aprile and her colleagues have wired a succession of vats containing liquid xenon with photomultipliers and different sensors. The hope is that her crew’s machine — far underground to defend it from cosmic rays and different worldly types of interference — would spot the uncommon collision between a WIMP and a xenon atom. The collision ought to end in a flash of sunshine and a cloud {of electrical} cost.

Up to now, it hasn’t happened.

The newest model, referred to as Xenon1T, ran from 2016 to 2018 with two tons of xenon because the goal.

Luca Grandi of the College of Chicago defined that in its most up-to-date evaluation of that experiment, the crew had seemed for electrons, quite than the heavier xenon nuclei, recoiling from collisions. Amongst different issues, that may very well be the signature of particles a lot lighter than the putative WIMPs hanging the xenon.

Simulations and calculations urged that random occasions ought to have produced about 232 such recoils over the course of a 12 months.

However from February 2017 to February 2018, the detector recorded 285, an extra of 53 recoils.

Dr. Grandi stated, “We now have seen the surplus greater than a 12 months in the past, and now we have tried in any method to destroy it,” referring to the measurements.

The collaboration is within the closing phases of getting ready a much bigger, extra delicate model of its experiment. It was delayed by the coronavirus lockdown in Italy however might now begin up by the top of this 12 months.

If the surplus is actual, it ought to present up inside a month or two after it begins working, Dr. Grandi stated.

So for now, all three potentialities — axions, neutrinos or tritium — are nonetheless alive, he stated.

And so axions may very well be about to enter onto the principle stage of cosmology.

The story of axions begins in 1977, when Roberto Peccei, a professor on the College of California, Los Angeles, who died on June 1, and Helen Quinn, emerita professor at Stanford, urged a slight modification to the speculation that governs robust nuclear forces, ensuring that it’s invariant to the course of time, a characteristic that physicists take into account a necessity for the universe.

Each Dr. Wilczek and Steven Weinberg of the College of Texas at Austin independently realized that this modification implied the existence of a brand new subatomic particle. Dr. Wilczek referred to as it the axion, and the title caught.

“A number of years earlier than, a grocery store show of brightly coloured packing containers of a laundry detergent named Axion had caught my eye,” he associated in a recent essay in Quanta. “It occurred to me that ‘axion’ sounded just like the title of a particle and actually must be one.”

When he realized that the Peccei-Quinn concept implied a particle, he noticed his probability.

Axions have by no means been detected both instantly or not directly. And the speculation doesn’t predict their mass, which makes it laborious to search for them. It solely predicts that they might be bizarre and would barely work together with common matter. Theorists have imagined many variations of axions that would play completely different roles within the universe, together with being the darkish matter that, quite than WIMPS, fills the universe and binds galaxies. And though they don’t seem to be WIMPS, they share a few of these particles’ imagined bizarre skills, reminiscent of with the ability to float via Earth and our our bodies like smoke via a display door.

With a purpose to fulfill the necessities of cosmologists, nevertheless, such dark-matter axions would want to have a mass of lower than a thousandth of an electron volt within the models of mass and vitality most popular by physicists, in keeping with Dr. Turner. (By comparability, the electrons that dance round in your smartphone weigh in at half one million electron volts every.) What they lack in heft they might greater than make up for in numbers.

That may make particular person cosmic dark-matter axions too gradual and ethereal to be detected by the Xenon experiment.

However axions may be produced by nuclear reactions within the solar, and people “photo voltaic axions” would have sufficient vitality to ping the Xenon detector proper the place it’s most delicate, Dr. Grandi stated.

Photo voltaic axions wouldn’t be darkish matter, however verifying that they really exist could be a serious step towards opening up the chance that one other type of axion may very well be darkish matter, in keeping with Dr. Wilczek.

Different experiments are underway to attempt to detect cosmic darkish matter axions instantly. Amongst them are the Axion Dark Matter Experiment on the College of Washington, which makes use of a powerful magnetic area to detect the axions by watching them flip into microwaves. And an experiment at CERN in Switzerland, CAST for CERN Axion Solar Telescope, has additionally seemed for axions from the solar.

The opposite thrilling, although barely much less probably, chance is that the Xenon collaboration’s extra alerts come from the wispy particles known as neutrinos, that are actual, and peculiar, and zipping via our our bodies by the trillions each second.

Ordinarily, these neutrinos wouldn’t contribute a lot to the surplus of occasions the detector learn. However they might achieve this if that they had an intrinsic magnetism that physicists name a magnetic second. That may give them a better chance of interacting with the xenon and tripping the detector. Based on the usual lore, neutrinos, that are electrically impartial, don’t carry magnetism. The invention that they did would require rewriting the principles as they apply to neutrinos.

That, stated Dr. Weiner, could be “a really very huge deal,” as a result of it will indicate that there are new elementary particles on the market to search for — new physics.

Nonetheless, Dr. Weiner and others, together with the Xenon authors themselves, cautioned that each the axion and the magnetic neutrino hypotheses battle with astronomical observations.

Useless stars, like white dwarfs, which have used up their nuclear gas fade and funky off over time as they radiate their vitality away. In the event that they have been emitting axions or these magnetic neutrinos just like the solar, Dr. Weiner identified, they might be dropping vitality and fading quicker than what astronomers see. He referred to as this downside “a giant rigidity” that he and different theorists will probably be brainstorming.

Tritium stays one other fly within the ointment.

Hydrogen is the lightest and most plentiful component within the universe. Tritium is one in every of its isotopes, radioactive with a half-life of 12.three years. It’s principally produced by cosmic rays interacting with the ambiance and is utilized in hydrogen bombs to assist improve their explosive energy.

If the isotope is the reason for the surplus, the quantity that may trigger the readings is about “three tritium atoms per kilogram of xenon, actually an insanely low quantity,” Dr. Grandi stated. That’s nearly unimaginable to measure besides with an instrument as delicate because the Xenon detector, he stated.

It could prove, he admitted, that tritium explains the surplus and that tritium contamination will simply be yet another element that needs to be thought of or calibrated in future detectors.

“However after all we’re actually excited concerning the chance that these are precise alerts,” Dr. Grandi stated.

He added: “It’s pointing in direction of physics past the usual mannequin, so it’s a giant deal. So I believe it will be an essential discovery.”

Dr. Grandi is now in Northern Italy and is anxious to get again to Gran Sasso and begin the work of getting the following section of the Xenon experiment on-line.

Dr. Aprile, who’s leaving New York for Italy in just a few weeks, stated, “I’m principally excited, however the actually the thrill is it makes you are feeling so good that you’ve got a brand new detector developing.”

The universe is ready for a solution.

“We have to push,” Dr. Grandi stated, “And now I believe that, you realize, we could be sitting on one thing that could be actually thrilling.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here