A Disaster on the Minnesota Freedom Fund


Within the weeks following the killing of George Floyd, tens of thousands and thousands of {dollars} have flowed into small nonprofit organizations in Minnesota. Now many donors want to understand how these funds shall be distributed.

The Minnesota Freedom Fund, a bail fund that earlier this month solely had one full-time worker, has raised greater than $30 million alone since Mr. Floyd’s demise on Could 25. Its identify grew to become ubiquitous on social media as activists and celebrities posted screenshots of their donations to the fund and implored their followers to match them. (Bail funds increase cash to launch those that have been jailed, in order that they will await trial freely.)

On Monday, the fund introduced that it had contributed “properly over” $200,000 to bail funds within the weeks because the protests started. That revelation adopted an open letter addressed to 2 different organizations that had seen a surge in donations, Black Visions Collective and Reclaim the Block, asking that the nonprofits be extra clear about fund-raising and the allocation of funds.

After the Minnesota Freedom Fund shared the $200,000 determine, a number of commenters on Twitter expressed disappointment that such a small portion of the donations had been distributed. Some additionally famous that the fund’s board, because it had been depicted on its web site, appeared to be composed entirely of white people. (The net web page that lists the group’s employees has been eliminated at the least twice this month because the board’s membership has shifted.)

Any group as small because the Minnesota Freedom Fund — which is run by fewer than 10 individuals, together with its board — might need struggled beneath the load of such a sudden inflow of funding. “Unsure how any small group would spend $35 million in a matter of two weeks after they’ve by no means handled such a lot of cash of their lives,” tweeted Noname, a rapper who helped signal-boost the fund in late Could.

However the group was in a very troublesome place when it discovered itself within the highlight. It had already been grappling with questions in regards to the management of its solely full-time worker, Tonja Honsey.

In April, a page called “Tonja Honsey – Native Rachel Dolezal” appeared on Fb. Its directors alleged that Ms. Honsey, the fund’s govt director, was mendacity about her id as an Indigenous girl, evaluating her to Ms. Dolezal, the former Spokane, Wash., N.A.A.C.P. president who posed as a black woman for years.

The web page’s directors known as for Ms. Honsey to step down from all her organizing roles. The directors stated they’d not determine themselves to The New York Instances due to issues about their very own security, however stated they had been two native girls native to Minneapolis.

Ms. Honsey stated in an electronic mail that she was “not capable of speak to media at this level,” however that the Fb web page was “unfaithful.” She pointed to posts on the web page made by her mom, who wrote that her daughter was Indigenous “on her grandfather’s aspect.”

The Fb web page additionally carried a message that Ms. Honsey had been ousted from the group for points associated to these raised by the web page.

Ms. Honsey stated she might neither affirm nor deny whether or not she was nonetheless concerned with the fund.

“As a result of we’re in energetic arbitration, I’m unable to remark about that,” stated the Minnesota Freedom Fund’s present board president, Octavia Smith.

Ms. Smith and her predecessor, Greg Lewin, who was the board’s president till early June, stated that turmoil throughout the group had detracted from its general mission.

“Our capability is taxed for certain,” Ms. Smith stated. ”Our capability is certainly taxed.” She added that earlier than the nationwide protests, “our employees was solely a employees of 1.”

Mr. Lewin stated that the inner points — which he stated he was unable to touch upon intimately — didn’t inhibit the group’s skill to get individuals out of jail, however that it did “hamper our skill to maneuver and collaborate in the neighborhood.”

Mr. Lewin stated that the group sometimes identifies these in want of bail cash with the assistance of native public defenders, and that its course of trusted legal professionals’ involvement. That prevented the disruption associated to Ms. Honsey from instantly affecting the group’s work, he stated, but it surely additionally made for a extra restricted course of than many on-line might need anticipated.

“Being on the reins of a company getting this degree of consideration and assets is a special ballgame,” he stated. “That features public scrutiny. Individuals needs to be mad, keep mad, keep impatient for change. I’m undecided we’re the right automobile for that impatience however we get it.”

Mr. Lewin added that the criticism could possibly be irritating. “The left is exceedingly good at consuming its personal,” he stated.

“Individuals suppose as a result of we obtained cash we are actually a part of the system,” he continued. “It’s like, ‘No.’”

The Minnesota Freedom Fund was founded in 2016 by Simon Cecil, then a masters scholar on the College of Minnesota. Ms. Smith, a pal of Mr. Cecil’s, was the fund’s first worker, and have become its board president in 2018. In 2019, Ms. Smith stepped away from her common work with the fund however remained listed on its web site as “emeritus board president.”

On Could 31, although, she briefly reduce ties with the group altogether.

“I had some disagreements round management,” she stated. “That’s in all probability all I’m capable of say.”

Ms. Smith, who’s black, was requested to come back again to the board “in an effort to steward a simply transition of assets and energy,” she stated. On June 11, she was reinstated because the board’s president.

“Our board has traditionally been predominantly white, and we acknowledge that that’s an issue,” she stated.

The fund said on Twitter that it had paid “all protest-related bail that has come our manner.” Mr. Lewin stated that it had bailed out 40 individuals in June. Ms. Smith stated that the majority different individuals who had been detained in Minnesota had been cited and launched, and weren’t eligible for bail.

“We’d love to make use of that $30 million and get individuals out tomorrow,” she stated. “However the actuality is that the methods which are put in place to forestall that, to forestall black and brown individuals from having freedom, to forestall people who find themselves poor from having freedom, nonetheless exist. So we’re nonetheless navigating a poisonous system. Whereas additionally attempting to abolish it.”

Ms. Smith stated she understood why individuals had been upset.

“We’re scaling as much as meet the wants of the neighborhood whereas additionally attempting to scale our assets to satisfy the wants of those that are instantly impacted by the harms of mass incarceration,” she stated. “That requires deep care and intention. We’re transferring. That’s all I can say, that we’re transferring.”

In the intervening time, the fund is not accepting donations.

Ezra Marcus contributed reporting.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here